A/N: We've hit the halfway mark of this collection! 

Men

Mccree

Dogs (two, to be specific)

hoRSES

Just an entire petting zoo, honestly

Not even joking, get the man a petting zoo

He loves alpacas

Genji

His dragon

Maybe one dog

Maybe a dog and a cat

Also birds are great

Hanzo

His dragons

A cat

Or multiple dogs

Like four dogs

Big, cozy, happy doggos

Also lizards

He likes snakes too

Soldier 76

Dogs

Big dogs

None of those small yippy dogs

Just big ole dogs that think they're lap dogs

Reaper

Probably too scared about caring for another living creature to get a pet

Anyway, he's definitely a dog person

One nice cuddly dog

A fluffy dog

A very fluffy dog

A dog he could use as a pillow while laying on the floor

Lucio

Rescue animals, specifically

Rescue dogs, rescue cats

Probably mutts

He also likes small birbs

Roadhog

A pig

Come on, it's a given

It's named something cute, like Curly or Oinkers

Junkrat

Wants some fuckin' wild animal

Like a bear or a tiger

Raccoons, trust me on this

Reinhardt

bIG DOGS

Zenyatta

Birds

Lots of little, happy birbs with pretty chirps

Bird-friendly stray cats that he's fed and trained

Doomfist

One dog

A medium-sized good boy

He's trained it to sit on his back while he does push-ups and other things like that

Women

Sombra

Loves cats but they climb on everything

A miniature horse that acts like a dog

Symmetra

A cat that she's somehow managed to train

Fish!!

A giant fish tank full of pretty fish

Widowmaker

Not an animal person

Probably something really low maintenance

Maybe a tarantula

D.Va

Dog???

Dog!!

Big dogs!!!

But also cats??

Cats!!!!

A monkey??

A bear cub???

Animals!!

:D!!!!

Mercy

A couple cute lil birbs

Birbs that'll sit on her shoulders while she reads or works or does chores

Just happily tweeting

Also a cat trained not to hurt the birbs

Birb-friendly cat

Tracer

Dogs

Specifically medium-sized ones with lots of energy

Mei

A polar bear

She can't have a polar bear? Watch her.

Fine, maybe a couple bunnies instead

Zarya

Huskies

Two giant lap dog huskies

That's it, the end

Pharah

Honestly, would probably love reptiles

Propose to her with a giant snake and she'll marry you right then

Also she totally already has a pet turtle

Ana

A good ole dog

Thinks horses are pretty great too