[HEADCANON #1]

Toby has very sensitive hands, so whenever he kills he always wraps his hands in cloth to avoid getting calluses

[Credit to georgeroni]

[HEADCANON #2]

Toby is among the most antisocial pastas and he spends most of his time in his room reading and drawing

[HEADCANON #3]

Toby has to wear reading glasses

[HEADCANON #4]

Toby has a weird infatuation with candles, he's always burning one and has a large stash of them